It is perhaps the worst remake I have ever seen. I don't care about the characters and there is no emotional depth or connection for me. The only decent thing about it is the Bishop character (the US version of Herrick).
Sally is dull and boring, not a patch on Annie.
Josh, again I don't give two hoots about him, he is not as endearing as George.
The worst of all is saved for captain cardboard himself 'Aidan'. He was bad enough in Smallville but i'd take Mitchell any day.
I watch this show and feel nothing, yet the UK version has made me laugh and more recently broke my heart. Even the recently aired season (i'm still catching up) where the cast has had some alterations it is still far better than the US version.