Ok, objectively yes, he is handsome. No, not my type.
Especially on early Buffy when Boreanaz could not act, i was not enthralled with the puppy eyes. (Especially compared with him in his series, which I followed first)
NOTE:I started as an Ats fan first, BtVS came later.
I loved the first 4 seasons of Angel - before the Connor/Cordelia vomitfest.
I really enjoyed Angel as a character on his series.
Boreanaz is *not* my physical type at all but in later roles, he has grown into his body and his face is more mobile and i find him somewhat engaging. He takes better care of himself than he did back in the Angel days when he began to gain weight. Large man with excess weight. Just no. Now he looks better though he is older. He learned JMs lesson - fit and healthy looks good on screen.
Angel is a fascinating character to watch, but I would not want to be in a relationship with anyone so utterly ruthless and wilful. He also tends to lie to friends/people he loves. I like straightforward people.
Spike and James Marsters are appealing to me. I find Spike electric on screen and he steals most scenes he is in. JM is thin, fit and inhabits his body in a way few men do. He feels alive wirh energy. I love that in both men and women.