Does this make Spike a better vampire then Angel?

[Jules]

Just answer this one question: If its my opinion that Buffy is actually a man, would I be wrong?

You can't debate/ have an opinion on that. Its an actual physical thing...not prone to a person's interpritation. It just is a definate answer. Someone's actions and their reasoning being it can be debated, people can reason out different meaning from it.

 

[Wicked]

But Jesse just showed you proof. Therefore its definate. You cant argue that.

 

[Schillaci]

You can't debate/ have an opinion on that. Its an actual physical thing...not prone to a person's interpritation. It just is a definate answer.

Thanks, bigot. Go tell that to thousands of people who are born of one sex but believe themselves to be another. You just prove that you don't believe your own point, you are not entering the debate with an open mind, or any objective reasoning.

Someone's actions and their reasoning being it can be debated, people can reason out different meaning from it.

That's called motive. You don't debate that Buffy stabbed Angel with a sword. That's called action.

 

[Jules]

Thanks, bigot. Go tell that to thousands of people who are born of one sex but believe themselves to be another. You just prove that you don't believe your own point, you are not entering the debate with an open mind, or any objective reasoning.

Now your picking a fight and don't start name calling because I can guarantee you'll come worse off...you asked was Buffy a man...and I said that can't be debated...your now saying it can and that Buffy could be linked with those thousands of people who are born one sex but have the emotions of the other.

Its as if your purposely trying to not see my point.....

So I think it would be best....before this starts to get really ugly...that things are just left as they are...you think one thing and I don't agree and vice versa, we're both not going to agree with each other no matter what's said!

 

[Black Eye Guy]

Can we loose the name calling and insults people, and keep on topic! 🙂

 

[Edmund Blackadder]

I really don't see how people can argue what Spike went for.
Like stated, its debatable why he went for his Soul, but the fact that the people who created the show implicitly state this shows that was the intention.

Having an opinion based on open text is one thing, but to totally disregard closed text leaving no room for interpretation is, quite frankly, as silly as the Silliest Man from Sillyshire doing a silly walk down silly street on the silliest day of the year wearing a silly costume made from silly string while its raining.

 

[nerd4hire]

I'm going to close this as it goes over the posting per thread limit.

Post another if you like though. When it stayed on-topic it was an interesting discussion.