Gellar: New 'Buffy' movie is 'dumbest idea ever'

Aloverssoulz

Potential
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
471
Location
Ireland
Gellar: New 'Buffy' movie is 'dumbest idea ever'

Several cast members of the much-beloved series "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" have weighed in on the upcoming Joss Whedon-less "Buffy" movie, and now Buffy herself, Sarah Michelle Gellar, has made her feelings known.

"It was a movie. It's been made. It stars Kristy Swanson. They don't need to make another one," she said in an interview with CNN on Tuesday. "I think it's a horrible idea! To try to do a 'Buffy' without Joss Whedon? To be incredibly non-eloquent, that's the dumbest idea I've ever heard!"

Gellar is planning to return to series television for the first time since 2003 in a pilot for CBS called "The Ringer."

"I miss television, I do. It took me a while to understand that I missed it," she said. "Eight years is a really long time, especially at my age, being so young and not knowing other things and you realize you miss the familiarity, you miss the crew, you miss - it's almost like summer vacation and seeing your friends after the break."

Gellar went on to say that having a child motivated her to seek the stability of a regular series. It's also motivated her to join with the "Nestle Share the Joy of Reading Program," and to consider possibly writing a children's book in the future.

"It's a tough market to crash," she said. "It's been on my radar for a very long time. I've never fancied myself a writer, so we'll see."

Gellar visited the Los Angeles Public Library's historic Central Library on Tuesday to promote the program, which encourages continued reading over the summer.

"I love books. I'm constantly afraid that we're moving into this digital era where books are going to go away," Gellar says. "To me books are the basis for everything in life. Reading is how we function, it's not just creative imagination and creative play, it's how we function as human beings, as adults, and if you can instill that at a young age that's a skill they have for life."
Post by: CNN.com associate producer Henry Hanks

source: http://marquee.blogs.cnn.com/2011/05/11/gellar-new-buffy-movie-is-dumbest-idea-ever/

Nice to hear her thoughts 😀

I still don't get why nobody is being perfectly honest about their feelings on the movie though. They say it'll fail and that it's not smart, but they seem to be holding back. If I was Joss i'd be bashing the crap out of the movie and all those that will work on it 😛
 
Last edited by a moderator:
They probably don't want to hardcore bashing because it might actually turn out to be a success, or what if some of their friends get cast in the movie?? Awkward!!
 
M
Marisa
lol true what if someone like Freddie was cast in it yes it would be awkward to say the least.
Ha, saying it will fail and trashing the idea by saying it is stupid is pretty blunt, IMO. There's no holding back, maybe only a censoring of a swear word here or there. People who don't have tact - like Mr Trump - with their opinions tend to get lotsa backlash. Though not mainstream media news, I don't think anyone is being shy about their opinions.

Also, is this film even being made? There's not much excitement coming from anyone and I'm sure studios might be a tad nervous about that.

Also, I'm so happy to see so much Sarah lately. Like, uber happy. Cannot WAIT for Ringer.
 
NY State of Mind
NY State of Mind
[No message]
brinkster130
brinkster130
[No message]
I actually think the way they are acting is already completely inappropriate, rude and lacking in self reflection. They are completely trashing something that they don't really know to much about from the sounds of things. I mean they were in a TV show called Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Get over yourselves guys. It's really putting me off some of the stars.
 
I
Icarium
[No message]
T
Thamior
[No message]
BuffangelLovE
BuffangelLovE
[No message]
I actually think the way they are acting is already completely inappropriate, rude and lacking in self reflection. They are completely trashing something that they don't really know to much about from the sounds of things. I mean they were in a TV show called Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Get over yourselves guys. It's really putting me off some of the stars.

Thanks for saying that! I hope they make the movie and it turns out great. We need more stories!
 
S
Spikefan31
[No message]
I actually think the way they are acting is already completely inappropriate, rude and lacking in self reflection. They are completely trashing something that they don't really know to much about from the sounds of things. I mean they were in a TV show called Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Get over yourselves guys. It's really putting me off some of the stars.

I see Buffy the Vampire Slayer as much the casts and writers show as it is Joss Whedon's. The show would never have become the hit it was without Sarah, David and everyone else. They have every right to bash the movie and those making it because it's them that made the show what it was. Not the scum that is making the new movie. Legally they may own the rights to Buffy, but that's as far as it goes.
 
Z
zobothehobo
I was with you until scum. I don't think it's fair to call these people scum because I don't know them.
D
dan k
Buffy The Vampire Slayer is all about the cast of the television show for me. Without them there is no Buffy
I actually think the way they are acting is already completely inappropriate, rude and lacking in self reflection. They are completely trashing something that they don't really know to much about from the sounds of things. I mean they were in a TV show called Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Get over yourselves guys. It's really putting me off some of the stars.
I am kind of starting to agree with this. If Candice is casted as Buffy they have me sold because I really do love her. I was against it at first but I mean what if it turns out good?
I do however think Joss should have wrote it.
I agree Zeppo it is good to hear from Sarah I will be tuning into her show.
 
NY State of Mind
NY State of Mind
[No message]
P
prophecygrrl
who's Candice?
S
svp
@prophecygrrl: Candice Accola, from the Vampire Diaries. She's kind of fantastic :)
I see Buffy the Vampire Slayer as much the casts and writers show as it is Joss Whedon's. The show would never have become the hit it was without Sarah, David and everyone else. They have every right to bash the movie and those making it because it's them that made the show what it was. Not the scum that is making the new movie. Legally they may own the rights to Buffy, but that's as far as it goes.

What exactly makes the people involved in the new movie 'scum'? That's a pretty offensive and horrible word to use considering that we don't really know many concrete facts about the creative team behind it just yet, and there has definitely been absolutely ZERO confirmations on cast yet.

It just sounds bitter and, sorry to be blunt but, incredibly geeky to start bashing something and someone just because it's not someone that you look up to with a bizarre God complex like view.
 
Z
zobothehobo
What's bad about being "incredibly geeky"? I think you have a point, but saying that's blunt and acting like it's a bad thing is kind of offensive to me
Washburne
Washburne
[No message]
Sarah's thoughts were totally what I thought too when I first heard about it. I am SOOOOOO sick and tired of reboots of everything. Please, Hollywood, think and come up with something original.

Maybe it's just my age...a generational thing, perhaps?
 
Angelic Slayer
Angelic Slayer
[No message]
VisionGirl
VisionGirl
True, it's like nobody in Hollywood has a single original idea in their head anymore!
S
sisterofmercy
[No message]
Gum Gnome33
Gum Gnome33
So true
I don't know, on the one hand I can definitely see where you guys are coming from, it really isn't professional to be bashing an upcoming film like that. And if Joss had been even a little involved in the new movie I would 100% agree. But I guess the way I see it is this is a franchise-- a world-- that Joss created, fought for and built up over the last two decades. And maybe it's just the fangirl inside me, but I think it's a bit of a slap in the face for Joss to have a story that he's still telling (through Season 9) remade without any input from him or his team. Especially if they are in fact retelling the story of Buffy and her friends, when they could have just as easily approached the movie from the perspective of a new slayer character.

Don't get me wrong, if/when this does happen I'll be as curious as the next person to see what they did with it. But to me, it's just not Buffy the Vampire Slayer without its creator at the helm. And again, especially when Season 9 is still going strong.

Anyway, that's just me. I can see where you're coming from, but I guess I'm still a little too attached to the old Buffy to think that rationally 🙂silly🙂. Back to the topic: I'm glad to see Sarah finally weighed in on the reboot. Just about every other cast member has and I was really interested to hear her take on the idea, since she played the character for so long. Thanks for sharing ALS 🙂
 
Z
zobothehobo
[No message]
brinkster130
brinkster130
[No message]
Sarah's thoughts were totally what I thought too when I first heard about it. I am SOOOOOO sick and tired of reboots of everything. Please, Hollywood, think and come up with something original.

Maybe it's just my age...a generational thing, perhaps?

How can it be a generation thing? Reboots have been hugely popular for many decades. Look at how many times Romeo and Juliet has been remade. How about Little Red Riding Hood? Retelling stories that people like can be a wonderful expression of creativity.
 
Reboots these days have a lot to do with technology advancements and knowing that there is already an audience built for it. Big studios hate risks, that's what independent movies do (as they have creative control and are mostly about the art). And the independent ones that draw attention the studios buy. Lovely circle of life! lol. Generation thing may not be the right word but I get what ya mean. In the case of Romeo and Juliet, that's a copyright-less story that doesn't cost a penny to screw around with. I just bought Baz's version (with Leo DiCaprio and Claire Danes); gotta love creative license!
 
I can kind of see where the people saying it's not professional are coming from, but as Angelic Slayer said, to me it kind of feels like a slap in the face to Joss. I mean it's HIS idea that he had to fight for. He had this idea and wrote a movie that was god awful because he didn't direct it. Then he fought to adapt it into a television show. Then spent 7 years with a successful cast and made a great show. THEN he moved the story to comics. And he is STILL telling the story. I might be able to back this thing if the story was over and done with and it had been a little time... but it's not. And even if the story DID end with the show.. it hasn't even been ten years yet!

I guess what I'm trying to say is to me, it feels just as unprofessional and rude to even be MAKING this movie without Joss as it does for the actors who worked hard to make Buffy what it is to publicly bash this movie.
 
Angelic Slayer
Angelic Slayer
Exactly my thoughts, but worded better! lol
S
sisterofmercy
[No message]
brinkster130
brinkster130
[No message]
I still think people shouldn't be bashing this movie until we hear more details about it. But as far as news come, it's been totally dead for months now. So, maybe they're just gonna drop it, hmm?
 
zobothehobo agrees: What's bad about being "incredibly geeky"? I think you have a point, but saying that's blunt and acting like it's a bad thing is kind of offensive to me

Being a geek isn't completely a bad thing, I'm proud to be an amazing geek, but the Godlikepraise that we all seem susceptable to is definitely one of the less attractive qualities about us geeks.
 
Z
zobothehobo
Oh the crazy enthusiasm and godlike praise is kinda one of my favorite thing about being a geek
P
prophecygrrl
yeah, sometimes the godlikepraise is way too much.
I can kind of see where the people saying it's not professional are coming from, but as Angelic Slayer said, to me it kind of feels like a slap in the face to Joss. I mean it's HIS idea that he had to fight for. He had this idea and wrote a movie that was god awful because he didn't direct it. Then he fought to adapt it into a television show. Then spent 7 years with a successful cast and made a great show. THEN he moved the story to comics. And he is STILL telling the story. I might be able to back this thing if the story was over and done with and it had been a little time... but it's not. And even if the story DID end with the show.. it hasn't even been ten years yet!

I guess what I'm trying to say is to me, it feels just as unprofessional and rude to even be MAKING this movie without Joss as it does for the actors who worked hard to make Buffy what it is to publicly bash this movie.

Couldn't Joss just put his foot down if he didn't want this to happen. I mean, it's gotta mean something that this was entirely his idea. Dosen't he have like a "copyright" (lol) per se to anything Buffy related? Kinda like George Lucas does with anything Star Wars related 😀
Anyway, on another note, happy to see so much of Sarah around recently! YAY
 
Z
zobothehobo
What Zeppo said
Unfortunately, Buffy wasn't independently produced. It was funded by a studio, so a studio bought the Buffy franchise and Joss ran it. The studio can do what they want with the Buffy name but cannot use what Joss did as the studio didn't create what happened on the show; he did. So, if they use his story without his approval or involvement that's creative copyright infringement and Joss can take action against that. The producers that funded the Buffy name own it technically, thus can do this reboot. Joss will receive royalties for it as his idea is the basis for it, however.
 
Scarlett Blade
Scarlett Blade
ah, okay, that makes sense. Thanks!
I think Joss should be apart of it but then again it may turn out great. I personally don't think Joss is the best thing to walk the earth writing wise. I think he is pretty good though. I have been thinking about this a lot lately I feel like he should have been apart of it but I have watched some things where the original creator left but the show/franchise was still as good if not better.

I am kind of glad not mad anymore that the originals aren't going to be in it. It could have been a flop then everyone would have made fun of the Buffy we all love.
 
caitaintdead
caitaintdead
[No message]
P
prophecygrrl
[No message]
Gum Gnome33
Gum Gnome33
Actually I have to say that I'm worried people who have never seen it will think this movie represents it, even if it doesn't and it totally flops. Ugh
zobothehobo agrees: Oh the crazy enthusiasm and godlike praise is kinda one of my favorite thing about being a geek

The crazy enthusiasm is totally my favourite part of being a geek. And the collecting. I like the collecting.
 
M
Marisa
I like the collecting even though it is becoming a problem but what can we do?
Back
Top Bottom