I hate this season with a friggin passion. It's honestly just a dumbed down version of the show.
BtVS has always been some of the highest quality TV ever produced, and even though there were seasons that weren't as strong, like Season 4, it always had individual episodes that were pieces of art, an example being Hush, Once More With Feeling, The Body, Surprise/Innocence, The Zeppo, and Prophecy Girl, among others. Season 7 has none of those, there are no episodes that take risks or try to do anything special, the only one I feel comes close is "Storyteller", but it doesn't hold up to some of the other great episodes. I never liked The First either, he isn't the worst, and I did like how he manipulated everyone, but I give more credit to the actors. Overall, I just found him generic
And then there's the Potentials....I don't think I've ever hated something more on TV in my life. This is what ruined the season for me, but I would like to say the concept could have worked, but it was just poorly executed. My main complaint is that the Potentials got more focus than Xander, Giles, Willow, and Dawn....WHY!?!? Why would you make the last season of the show ignore the characters that made the show great in the first place, IT MAKES NO SENSE. No one likes these Potentials more than the Core Four (I feel pretty safe saying this), so why push these annoying ass characters?
Xander and Giles didn't do anything all season, unless you want to include Xander dating Ashanti. And another complaint, why was Faith in this season? She is such a dynamic and interesting character...instead the writers brought her back to have sex with Robin Wood, WTF. She did reconcile with Buffy and become more of a leader, but the expense was even less focus on the characters. She should have stayed on Angel, at least that season was well thought out (well except the Jasmine part) and she could have achieved the exact same things.
No, No, No, there's more. Why did the writers not use this season to fix the Scoobies relationship? It is clearly broken, or not as strong as in seasons 1-3 (you can take your pick). Instead we got Buffy telling Giles she had nothing else to learn from him...WTF, and what's even worse she never apologized. Then we have the Scoobies not spending their last night together, instead they all chose someone else. And who's idea was "Chosen"? Buffy has always been about subversion, and being original, but what we got was some generic giant battle, which was good, but should not have been the conclusion to a 7 year story, especially one as good as Buffy. Thank goodness "Not Fade Away" was way better...
And Kennedy sucks.