No spoilers please: My reviews of each Buffy episode on my first watch

Hm, I actually found Witch to be one of the standouts of S1. The twist was just so unprecedented.

I don't think this counts as a spoiler, just a warning: Many episodes from S1, more so than the other seasons, are standalones such as this. After all, the initial concept of Buffy was making 'high school is hell' literal--in this case, a mother literally takes steps to relive her glory days.
 
Hm, I actually found Witch to be one of the standouts of S1. The twist was just so unprecedented.

I don't think this counts as a spoiler, just a warning: Many episodes from S1, more so than the other seasons, are standalones such as this. After all, the initial concept of Buffy was making 'high school is hell' literal--in this case, a mother literally takes steps to relive her glory days.

The twist definitely saved the episode for me, I thought it was really effective. I don't have any particular problem with standalone episodes (one of my favourite shows at one point was Ghost Whisperer, and that was almost entirely composed of these types of episodes for the first three seasons). It's just that I didn't find "Witch" to be a particularly evocative standalone episode, sadly. 🙂
 
Have to say I love that your doing this! Cant wait for your review of the next episode! I luckily managed to watch them all in order as well as I flukily caught the first one on BBC2 all those years ago and became obsessed! Its interesting to see how peoples opinions vary depending on when they picked the series up, even if they have since watched earlier episodes.
 
Have to say I love that your doing this! Cant wait for your review of the next episode! I luckily managed to watch them all in order as well as I flukily caught the first one on BBC2 all those years ago and became obsessed! Its interesting to see how peoples opinions vary depending on when they picked the series up, even if they have since watched earlier episodes.

Thank you, I hope you enjoy the rest of my reviews. 🙂

It's really interesting watching this series so long after it initially aired. It's held up pretty well overall so far, especially considering that this is considered the weakest season.
 
Although, the scene of Willow's confrontation with Cordelia and her clever use of deception (causing Cordelia to delete her maligned computer program) is definitely my favourite moment of the show so far.
"Press Deliver" Hahaha! Although in today's day and age, a high school student who knows so little about computers is the thing that's truly laughable. 😉

What did you think about Jesse becoming a vampire and then being killed so soon into the series?
 
"Press Deliver" Hahaha! Although in today's day and age, a high school student who knows so little about computers is the thing that's truly laughable. 😉

What did you think about Jesse becoming a vampire and then being killed so soon into the series?

I thought the fact that Jesse had become a vampire and placed as a trap for Buffy was an excellent twist. Although, as for the character himself, I didn't particularly remember him from the pilot episode very well, so I wasn't shocked by his death as much as I probably should have been. Maybe I should rewatch the pilot at some point. 😛
 
What a great thread- really enjoying your reviews!! 🙂

Did you like Buffy's "macho macho man" singing in The Witch? That was the highlight for me haaa

🙂
 
Here's my review of the fourth episode of Buffy - "Teacher's Pet."

Just as a heads-up, I might not be able to watch the fifth episode of the series tonight, so there may not be a review tomorrow. If I have time however, I'll try to fit the episode in. Sorry about that.

After Buffy's science teacher goes mysteriously missing, Angel arrives with a warning for Buffy - something is coming. Buffy and the Slayerettes take it upon themselves to discover what happened to the missing professor, while Xander falls for the deceptively deadly substitute.

After my mild disappointment with the previous episode of Buffy, I was looking forward to seeing whether the series could get back on track with "Teacher's Pet," which marks my completion of the first-third of season one. This episode struck me as the most gruesome and disturbing of the series thus far, and thankfully enabled the show to continue its high-quality run.

The episode opened with Buffy in science class, being asked questions about the previous night's homework. Being her ne'er-do-well self, Buffy flunked the questions, rather humourously trying to guess the answers from a miming Willow. I enjoy the relationship between the three main teenagers, especially that of Willow and Buffy. They genuinely feel like a closely-knit group of friends, who would go to great lengths to protect one another. Giles too seems to be a true friend to this group (although I still have my suspicions that he may be hiding something). The science professor, Dr. Gregory, asked Buffy to stay after class. I really loved the scene with the two of them, as Dr. Gregory spoke to Buffy about her permanent record and generally poor reputation among the teachers. He seemed to actually care for her, offering her advice about improving academically and helping her with the previous night's homework. It was nice to see that someone outside of her friends and mother actually cared for Buffy - which made the rest of the episode somewhat difficult to watch.

The following scene heralded the return of Angel, who had been absent from the previous episode. He seems to be already showing affection for Buffy, offering her his jacket when he believed her to be cold. His purpose at the Bronze was to warn Buffy about yet another imminent threat - whom Buffy laughably dubbed 'Fork Guy' after seeing the slashes on Angel's arm.

Dr. Gregory quickly went missing after being attacked by a creature of some kind in his lab. Xander, who's inherent lust for the contact of a woman I seem to be already tired of (although it actually made sense in this episode), quickly grew attracted to the substitute science teacher, Natalie French. Of course, it was clear to me early on that Ms. French was not simply an ordinary substitute, but something far more sinister. The teacher showed a strong knowledge and interest in insect life - specifically, that of the praying mantis - which quickly made me suspicious as to who, or what, she really was (the giant claw of an insect could be seen grabbing Dr. Gregory earlier in the episode).

The ill-fated Dr. Gregory was soon found in the cafeteria storage cupboards, decapitated and bitten. Buffy, who was clearly shaken by the discovery (it was nice to see her as shocked as everyone else for once), visited Weatherly Park to investigate a previous murder with a similar modus operandi. Among the drunks and homeless people lay a vampire, jumping out of the bushes to attack Buffy. The vampire had a claw on its hand, similar to that described by Giles previously in the episode. Of course, once the attack subsided, the 'twist' of the episode occurred: the vampire approached Ms. French on the sidewalk, only to sprint away in fear of her. Of course, this wasn't much of a shock to me - I've grown suspicious of sudden guest characters in standalone episodes, especially in a series such as Buffy.

The tension quickly escalated as Buffy saw Ms. French's head turn 180 degrees the following day. Obviously now aware that something was awry, Buffy enlisted the help of Giles and Willow to perform their respective tasks - Xander, once again, was doing nothing of much consequence, visiting the teacher's house at night to help with a science fair project (and become her next meal in the process). In a nice piece of character development, and as a legacy from Dr. Gregory, Buffy knew that the praying mantis could rotate its head in the same way that she had seen the substitute teacher do. This led Giles to the assumption that Ms. French was a shapeshifter of some kind, capable of changing her physical appearance to maintain normality around humans. I do enjoy watching the group work these sorts of mysteries out, they work well together as a team and the dialogue always flows smoothly - I just wish that Xander could finally integrate his way off of the sidelines and perform a meaningful job.

The group set out to rescue Xander, and another student who had been taken hostage, from the abomination that turned out to be their substitute. As it turns out, the teacher was using the pheromones secreted by insects to attract the men around the school to her. Here is where I found the most disturbing depiction of evil in the series thus far. Once she had lured her victims to her home, the shapeshifter would produce mantis eggs, using the men as fertilisers for her children. As she was mating with her prey, the mantis proceeded to bite their heads off. In addition, the victims had to be virgins (does that mean that old Dr. Gregory was still a virgin, or was he just a necessary casualty?). This fact, naturally, quite humourously embarrassed Xander when Buffy and the other Slayerettes turned up and saved his life (showing resourcefulness yet again by forcing the vampire with the claw to lead them to the correct house). I really feel as though the series should rush past Xander's obsession with Buffy, and enable him and Willow to become a couple. Willow shows such innocent, natural love of Xander that I think they would make an excellent pair. Her reaction to the way in which the mantis killed its prey was lovely:

"No, no, no, see, Xander's... I like his head. It's where you find his eyes and his hair and his adorable smile."​

I have to say that the make-up in this episode was once again excellent. The praying mantis looked fantastic for this early stage in the series, and is a true testament that computer generated graphics aren't always the way to go - they were obviously not widely available on television shows when Buffy was created. The way in which the mantis was killed was also unique and smart - using the creature's real-life weaknesses (bat sonar and bug spray) to cripple its nervous system. The excellent humour was also on display when Buffy tried to play the sonar but instead accidentally began a recording of Giles' notes.

My favourite moment of the episode arrived at the very end. Leaving her science class, Buffy found and picked up Dr. Gregory's broken glasses. It was heartfelt to see her show some real care and emotion about losing the one teacher who seemed to care for her. As she put the glasses safely back in his coat, I could tell that she was truly sorry for what had happened to him.

As always, here are a few of my extra thoughts throughout the episode:
  • I really enjoy the opening credits of this series, they have a very fun retro feel to them nowadays.
  • Giles' comparisons of the She Mantis to other mythological creatures was fascinating - the Sirens, for example. I always enjoy watching this character simply speak.
  • Angel promised that he will be around, yet I'm still curious as to how he will integrate himself. Buffy showed an obvious attraction to him at the end of the episode, too.
  • The principal will definitely become a frequent annoyance to Buffy, as he forced her to undergo counselling after Dr. Gregory's death. Also, was he being played by a different actor?
Overall, this episode of Buffy was a definite hit in my opinion. I loved the character development of the titular character throughout the episode (for me, this entire episode was about humanising her; showing that she does indeed have a heart under the mask), although I wish that Xander could finally get some meaningful tasks to perform. The storyline was a definite improvement upon the third episode, and while there were no jaw-dropping twists, it was by far my favourite episode since the series premiere. Hopefully the next episode can continue with this momentum.

As always, if you would like to discuss spoilers about my observations - or simply truly make fun of my naivety - please do so in this spoiler thread: https://www.buffy-boards.com/showthread.php?t=58905

Otherwise, please comment below and give me your thoughts on my review, thank you. 🙂
 
I really like your reviews 🙂 Unlike some, they don't make me want to bang my head against a brick wall. 😛
 
Very nice, any change on favourite characters? Whats intriguing you most?
 
What a great thread- really enjoying your reviews!! 🙂

Did you like Buffy's "macho macho man" singing in The Witch? That was the highlight for me haaa

🙂

I can't believe I forgot to mention that in my review, I think I was so amazed by it that I forgot to take notes. 😛

Please please please, keep these coming!!!!!

I'll be sure to, thanks for the encouragement. 🙂

I really like your reviews 🙂 Unlike some, they don't make me want to bang my head against a brick wall. 😛

Thank you very much. I'm glad that my reviews don't cause you potential brain damage. 🙂 😛

Very nice, any change on favourite characters? Whats intriguing you most?

Thanks. I still think Willow and Buffy are tussling over the top spot, although Giles is quickly becoming a favourite of mine too. I think the thing that's intriguing me most about the show is what I don't know about the story. I'm looking forward to finding out more about Buffy's past, where storylines are going to go and where some character's true allegiances lie.

I think this is a good opportunity to also thank all of you for being to thoughtful about not spoiling any future plot developments for me, this really is a fantastic community. 🙂

Also, I'm going to watch episode five now, so there should be a review tomorrow. 🙂
 
[S1][E5] Buffy the Vampire Slayer - "Never Kill a Boy on the First Date" review

Here's my review for the fifth episode of Buffy, "Never Kill a Boy on the First Date"

I hope you enjoy my review. 🙂

If you would like to discuss spoilers about my observations - or simply truly make fun of my naivety - please do so in this spoiler thread: https://www.buffy-boards.com/showthread.php?t=58905

Otherwise, please comment below and give me your thoughts on my review, thank you. 🙂

As Buffy longs for a normal life, the Master plots to fulfill an ancient prophecy concerning the creation of the 'Anointed,' a weapon which could finally rid of the vampire slayer for good.

While I had enjoyed the past two stand-alone episodes of Buffy, I had been looking forward to getting back to the main arc of the season and seeing exactly what the Master had up his sleeve. I had hoped that the series could establish itself a stronger foothold through building up the tension and developing the main storyline of the series. The fifth episode of the season brought back the vampires in force, which, along with unique and interesting ideas of its own, crafted what has been the best episode to date.

The episode opened with Giles observing Buffy fighting a vampire in the cemetery. As sort of an evaluation exercise, he determined that Buffy was exerting far to much energy fighting each creature, and that she should simply slay one and move on to the next - as an alternative, she could also surely drop the puns just before each kill, although that would take half of the fun out of each of these encounters. Soon after the exercise was complete, Giles noticed that the vampire had dropped a ring with an insignia of the Order of Aurelius on it - which was later revealed to be an ancient vampire sect. Confused as to why a vampire was carrying around such an object, Giles investigated further, propelling the episode into its main story arc. The intrigue in this episode was of definite advantage for the series; while the previous two episodes had been good, they were sorely missing any sort of mystery. The new Order added a lot of excitement to the proceedings, and I was captivated by potentially finding out exactly what it was by the end of the episode.

This episode seemed to be almost completely split in half story-wise. The other major plot developments again concerned the titular character. Buffy, who has quite a bit of difficulty sustaining an adequate social life, felt as though she needed a break from her role as Slayer. Rather ideally, a potential new character in the form of Owen was kind enough to ask her out on a series of dates throughout the episodes. Buffy, much to the dismay of an increasingly-anxious Giles, agreed to meet Owen at the Bronze. I thoroughly enjoyed seeing this side to Buffy; a young woman looking to establish herself in the social life around her high school. The excellent dialogue between Buffy and Owen also helped sell that these were simply normal teenagers, secretly admiring one other:
"So, Emily Dickens, huh? She's great."
"Dickinson."
"She's good also."​

The series seems to be really wishing to develop the main character throughout each episode, which is a fantastic goal to have for any series, but is also one which is rarely met. In addition, it was actually believable. After an overnight lookout with Giles, Buffy figured that nothing terrible was going to happen over the course of the next few nights, and rightfully believed that she could have a bit of fun. What makes this story so organic is that I've rarely seen Buffy engage in any form of social event completely removed from slaying before now. Of course, in order to keep in-character, Buffy also removed herself from the social scene once she discovered the dangers facing her friends. The writer's seem to meticulously follow what has previously happened in the series, while also paving out new directions for it to proceed, all while remaining completely natural in the process.

In another nice development, the Master finally returned to the series in this episode. His scenes are always a favourite of mine, as he always seems to revel in being pure, uncensored evil. While he hasn't had much of an opportunity to work outside of his prison in the underground, he always comes across as a formidable threat to Buffy. His goal this episode (and what the prophecy set forth by the Order of Aurelius predicted was to happen around the time-frame of the episode) was to raise an insatiable demon known as the 'Anointed,' which could be used in the battle against the Slayer. It was predicted that Buffy herself would be unable to contend with this creature's feral might, and that she would be brought down by the beast. Of course, Giles also soon uncovered this plan, and set out to prevent the Anointed from rising from the ashes of five dead people.

By far my favourite aspect of this episode was the sound design. More so than in previous episodes, the ambiance and effects heard throughout the episode truly impressed me. Once the fact that the Anointed would rise from the ashes of five was established, the scene quickly cut to that of a bus - filled with five civilians. As if this would not raise the tension in this scene enough, the music heard dramatically aided the sense of unease. The mutterings and prophetic preachings of a man on the bus established instantly that something was about to go horribly wrong for this group. The character could be heard gradually increasing the intensity of his speech, growing from a barely audible whisper to shouting down the bus at his companions. Of course, the bus was quickly ambushed by vampires - the screeching of tyres and death-cry from the horn of the bus signalling that the Anointed was about to be born.

Once Giles decided to check the funeral home following the deaths of the five victims, he was quickly attacked by vampires (yet, smartly, produced a cross to fend them off). The resulting intensity of the following scenes was palpable. Supposedly destroying her date with Owen, Buffy rushed to Giles' rescue with Willow and Xander in pursuit. Splitting up, Buffy and Giles decided they needed to investigate the morgue for the potential Anointed, while Xander and Willow occupied a naive Owen in the observation room. Once again, the ambiance kicked in once the group saw a corpse in the adjacent room rise and smash the window between them - the Anointed had indeed risen. The knowledge that Buffy could likely not defeat this vampire meant that the chase through the funeral home was far more intense than any of the previous battles - the mutterings and speeches of the Anointed dynamically echoing down the hallways behind them.

Perhaps the most disappointing aspect of this episode was the final confrontation with the Anointed (although the final twist somewhat alleviated this issue). It all seemed to be over so quickly and easily. With Buffy enraged after believing that the creature had killed Owen, she ducked out of the way as the monster dived for her - sending it head-first into the incinerator.

The final five minutes of the episode offered some fantastic character development for Buffy and (thankfully) Giles. Buffy ended up turning down Owen for a second date, with the fear of losing someone she cares about during her own struggles taking over. While it was nice to see her develop a social life outside of her core group, it was clear that she could tell that she has duties to perform - ones far larger than a simple date or party. It may be difficult to accept at times, but the greater good must be considered.

Giles also finally got some backstory to call his own - which actually turned out to be very interesting in its own right. As a child of ten-years-old, Giles was told by his father that he was to become a Watcher; the next in a long-line of men in his family to become one. Despite his wishes to become a fighter pilot (or a grocer), Giles was sat down and told that he had no choice in the matter - that sacrifice was needed in order to fulfill his supposed destiny. Comparisons to Giles' childhood and Buffy's are clear, with neither having much of a choice for their future. I hope this discussion brings the two closer together, as it's clear that they're already excellent friends.

I don't particularly have much else to mention about this episode, other than the final reveal that the Master has taken the child present on the ill-fated bus and plans for him to become the true Anointed, sent to mislead Buffy into his custody. Obviously this leads-in to future episodes, and made the underwhelming battle with the patsy in the morgue a little more tolerable.

Overall, this was by far my favourite episode of Buffy yet. Not only did it provide yet more character development, and offer a startling sound design, but it has also established a story for future episodes to build upon. I look forward to discovering what exactly the Master has planned for his new protégé, and how Buffy and her companions are going to deal with such encounters.
 
Another excellent review. I am really pleased that you are enjoying the show rather than just enduring it for scientific purposes 🙂
 
Awesome review! I love that you picked up on the emily dickens exchange between buffy and owen - and btw how cute was she running up and down the stairs after him. 🙂

Definitely keep these coming!
 
[S1][E6] Buffy the Vampire Slayer - "The Pack" review

Here's my review of the sixth episode of Buffy - "The Pack"

Enjoy 🙂

On a field trip to the zoo, Xander and other students are possessed by a mysterious pack of hyenas. As the group become more and more animal-like, and deaths begin to pile up, it is once again up to Buffy to set things right.


Marking the midway point for the first season of Buffy, the sixth episode offered up a few interesting ideas and plot directions, but it definitely gave me mixed feelings, far more than any of the previous episodes. I've often been told that, overall, the first season of Buffy hasn't aged very gracefully and that it is by far the weakest season of the series. Up to this point, I've never really noticed anything that seemed to be stricken down by the decade-and-a-half advancement in culture and the entertainment industry. This episode, however, definitely felt very aged to me.

The episode opened with Buffy and her classmates on a field trip to the zoo. A pack of bullies were shown ruthlessly poking fun at their peers, and entering a quarantined hyena sanctuary. Xander, who had been enraged by the group's antics, followed them in to the pen. Of course, this being Buffy, not all went according to plan, and the entire group (bar one unwilling participant) were possessed by the mysterious pack of hyenas. I can obviously not quite be sure as to how this plot was received by the public upon its initial airing, but even when previous episodes of Buffy are taken into consideration, I found this story to be preposterous. It simply seemed like a dull story to tell, with little-to-no tension present throughout since it was instantly obvious what had happened.

In addition, while the episode finally offered something substantial for Xander to work off of, I didn't particularly feel that it relieved any of my concerns for the character - I've been looking for Xander to become more active with his group of friends, not to become a completely new character for forty minutes. However, it was fun seeing a new, more sinister side to him. The gradual build-up of cockiness and insults throughout the episode worked fairly effectively, and it became clear just how much I've grown fond of Willow when Xander denounced his friendship with her in front of his new 'friends.' I became genuinely upset for Willow after seeing how embarrassed and hurt she was, and Alyson Hannigan is perfect for the role, bringing across just the right amount of emotion in every scene. The episode was also complicated when you consider Willow's affection for Xander, which was finally acknowledged (along with Buffy's interest in Angel) - there were a lot of mixed signals abounding when the insults began to fly:
"I've decided to drop Geometry, so I won't be needing your Math help anymore; which means I won't have to look at your pasty face again."​

I was quite surprised by how dark the episode got - especially considering the rather inadvertently silly premise - once the hyenas began to get hungry. Not only did the group slaughter and eat a raw pig on school property, but they also ate Principal Flutie. This was a pretty big shock, especially considering that I've thought Flutie would be a constant annoyance to Buffy and her friends during their otherworldly battles with evil (I'm sure long-time fans had a lot of fun with that naive assumption). It demonstrated that no matter how I may perceive the series, or what I believe is going to happen, the writers have a genuine talent for throwing curve-balls into the proceedings.

Some intrigue was created during the episode too, although it was overall nowhere near as interesting as the previous episodes' Order of Aurelius. The strange idea of animal possessions was explained through the introduction of a group of animal worshippers known as Primals. The group believe that humans are tainting and diluting the true meaning of life itself, and have uncovered methods of transferring the souls of feral creatures into their bodies. The eventual twist of the episode - that the zookeeper himself was a Primal, looking to transfer the souls of the hyenas into himself - wasn't quite as effective as previous similar twists, mostly due to the character's notable absence throughout a majority of the episode. He was brought into the storyline towards the end of the episode, nary five-to-ten minutes before his true motives were revealed.

The group of school students possessed by the hyenas did a good job in demonstrating certain traits specific to the creatures. In particular, the writers seemed adamant in demonstrating the creature's pack mentality. During a very fun game of dodgeball, the pack actually turned on their own teammate, isolating their victim before striking. The rest of the pack also came to Xander's aid after he was trapped in the library after attempting to fight Buffy. It was interesting to see these methods of hunting translated into human form, but I still didn't like the idea of the possessions.

Here are some of my general thoughts of the episode:
  • I'm annoyed the Xander quickly seems to be becoming the Daphne Blake of Buffy, constantly in need of saving from the villain-of-the-week.
  • I liked the correlation between Xander's real-life affection for Buffy and his hyena-persona's refusal to make fun of her.
  • This episode offered by far the worst pun in the series to date: "Didn't your mother ever tell you not to play with your food?"

Overall, I can't say that I was overly-satisfied with this episode. The premise of the episode itself felt instantly dated to me, and the execution also left something to be desired. Xander as a character is in some serious need of integration and relevance to the arching storyline, and while this episode got him some more screen-time, it failed to develop him at all. I hope that future episodes of Buffy can make me care about Xander, because at the moment, I'd actually prefer for him to be phased out of the show.

If you would like to discuss spoilers about my observations - or simply truly make fun of my naivety - please do so in this spoiler thread: https://www.buffy-boards.com/showthread.php?t=58905

Otherwise, please comment below and give me your thoughts on my review, thank you. 🙂
 
I'm very much enjoying your reviews, so I hope you keep them coming!!! They give me a giggle sometimes.

I've gotta say, though, that I disagree with this:

JustToClarify said:
This episode offered by far the worst pun in the series to date: "Didn't your mother ever tell you not to play with your food?"

I've always loved that line 😛
 
[MENTION=11924]JustToClarify[/MENTION] Are you posting up any more reviews?
 
Another great review, JTC! Please please please keep them coming! I love the way you write....but I have to say I have a much different view of this ep. It's actually one of my favorites.

I was bothered by Giles' disbelief of Buffy - dismissing her concern and saying Xander was just being a "teenage boy". However, I do like the turn around when he does allow for something more sinister to be happening "what are you gonna do?" "get my book...look stuff up." - which is the phrase buffy had just used when asking him for help.

Buffy really shows how strong she is here - when she says "you got anything to say to me?" after xander's horrible insult to willow and he just walks away laughing. he's afraid of her. Again this is shown when rather than throw the dodgeball at her the pack turns on their own teammate.

"How do you feel?"
"Like I've been hit with a desk."

I think Xander plays the evil role perfectly "look who just got bad" (not sure if that's the exact line)

the twist at the end actually got me - I love how giles puts it together just before getting knocked out

and the redeeming fact at the end that xander saves willow

also, I thought it was interesting that even though the zoo keeper was possessed with the hyena's soul the actual hyena's didn't recognize that - didn't take him as one of them - but instead ate him like they would any other human.

anyway - can't wait for your next one! 🙂
 
Back
Top Bottom