Okay, firstly, I thought the episode was a little slow. I mean, not THAT much happened.
I wish the fight scenes between Buffy and ubervamp were a little less one sided. I mean, he just totally kicked her ass, I didn't enjoy it all, because there wasn't any actual good FIGHTING in the fight scene. it was just him beating her up.
Dawn and Anya were great with the Andrew torture. I think he still has a role to play, otherwise, why is he still around? maybe HE'S the one to save the day this time 'round. lol.
I hadn't really thought about Giles being the First, but that's a VERY interesting thought. I was about to say that he gave Buffy the files on the First, but even that he didn't do, the girl took it out of her bag. Man... that scares me, that it could be Giles. But why have three SITs in the first place? Why not just kill them and show up as Giles anyway? It's not like he needs to gain Buffy's trust or anything. And if he IS the First, he'll know all about Buffy's go-get-'em plan!
The scene between Xander and Andrew was hilarious, when they both laughed at the same joke (I didn't get it, but the scene was funny).
About the thing that came out of Willow. obviously the First, but I thought he looked kind of LIKE the demon on Angel. now, I don't honestly think that it IS the demon on Angel, but it was weird. And why do the locator spell on the First? Why not do it on SPIKE?
That girl who ran away was stupid. just plain idiotic. I mean, REALLY. SHE was the one who was all "We're with the SLAYER... what could go wrong?" and then she runs away, and BECAUSE of her, Buffy gets beaten up so bad. GAH!
So what CAN kill this ubervamp anyway? HOw about WIllow mentioned-but-turned-into-an-orge-ball-of-sunshine-spell? the one from the episode where she released Anya's ex from the crystal? She was going to make a ball of sunshine to kill vamps. I mean yeah, this is the UBERVAMP, but I surprised she never tried it again.
And yeah... I don't know why water has any effect on Spike... uh, he's a vampire. he doesn't BREATHE. Angel was underwater for four months and HE didn't go unconscious.
Still freaked out about Giles possibly being the First...