Re-Watching "Once More, With Feeling."

AbraxasP3

Townie
Joined
Jan 3, 2013
Messages
31
Age
37
Location
Seattle, Wa
As I said in another post I am currently rewatching the entire series.
I just finished watching "Once More, With Feeling" and I actually really enjoyed it a lot.
Truth be told, when I saw this episode for the first time I thought it was extremely awkward and oddly placed not only in terms of what episode it was but also for what BtVS is know for...I would never have put a musical and BtVS together.
During my first viewing, I not only felt that it was awkward, but I was also cringing at it because I was really confused why they felt they needed to do such an episode...I thought the songs were not at all terrible but at the same time, I felt as if the whole experience was really out of place.

Having seen it for a second time, I not only appreciate the episode as a whole but I also can appreciate the music in terms of the lyrics and the meaning they convey in the BtVS universe. While I was watching just now, I really understood the placement of the songs in relation to the stories that were being told in the episode and in the season. The music was actually done very well and I think this is probably a large rarity in the television landscape... creatively speaking. I am actually going to watch it again for a third time because it is not only a fantastic BtVS episode, but also the singing gave me as a viewer more insight into the character development then a lot of the regular lines did for the entire season.
Did anybody else have any similar reaction or experiences with this particular episode?

---------- Post added at 01:45 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:38 AM ----------

With rewatching the entire series again I have become a very huge fan of this show. Having said that, I do not think this episode is something that you can only like if you are a major fan-- I think it's just something you kind of just have to see at least 1 more time to understand fully and appreciate.
Especially Sarah Michelle Gellar. One might be able to argue that her singing is the worst in the entire episode. But upon a second viewing, it is not only not that bad but it doesn't really matter because the lyrics mean so much more for the Buffy character.
 
I liked it more second time round - although I'm not a huge fan of musicals.

I really liked the scene with Xander and Anya - I still have that song in my head having only heard it twice in about ten years.
 
I was absolutely giddy the first time I watched it. I remember sitting on the edge of the couch, feeling like I was at the premiere of some huge movie or something. Now I still like the episode, but I feel like it's a bit overrated. I do think the songs were perfect to convey the story telling for each story arc in the show... Giles singing "Wish I Could Stay" is one of my favorite moments for his character in the entire show. Sadly, I was not impressed by James... Everyone kept saying James Marsters had such an amazing voice and I was so ready to hear him sing and when he did I kinda went "Umm.... People call that good?" He was okay, but I'm definitely not going to be rushing out to buy his albums. And as far as other bad singers, I think SMG gets a bad rap. I actually had heard a clip of her singing a while before "Once More With Feeling" aired, and was kinda cringing when I heard she was gonna be doing her own singing in the show, but I'm glad she did because a) she wasn't as bad as I was expecting her to be, and b) it lent a sense of realism that all the characters did their own singing.
 
absolutely giddy pretty much describes it for me! and every time I see it, it just gets better and better.

🙂!!!
 
Sadly, I was not impressed by James... Everyone kept saying James Marsters had such an amazing voice and I was so ready to hear him sing and when he did I kinda went "Umm.... People call that good?" He was okay, but I'm definitely not going to be rushing out to buy his albums.

Personally, I think James' voice is sexy. 😛 Spike's song was my favorite in the whole episode.
 
Spike's song was my favorite in the whole episode.

While my favorite is Something to Sing About, Rest in Peace is an awesome song. I also thought originally that they dubbed his voice, since it sounded nothing like Spike and I didn't know that James was American at that point. (He, Juliet, and Alexis had me fooled for quite a long time. Whedon finds good fake Brits, from my American point of view.)
 
Back
Top Bottom