SMG's body/weight preference

  • Thread starter Thread starter rene
  • Start date Start date

Which SMG do you prefer?

  • Earlier seasons (meatier)

    Votes: 8 61.5%
  • Later seasons (skinnier)

    Votes: 5 38.5%

  • Total voters
    13
R

rene

Guest
sarah's weight

sarah's weight has dropped drastically hasnt it? in season 1 she was plump 2nd season she was a little skinner and at the end of season 3 she was skinny then in season 4 she gained a little weight and sesons 5-7 she was skinnt but in season 7 she was skinner than ever! i dont know if this has already been discussed
 
And did you see her in scooby doo???Skinny as haidees!!!!HAHA!That is my new frase!Well...She is strange to be able to loose that much weight!But hey...I went from 123 to 102 in 2 months!So yea...I am skinny again!YAY!!!
 
God, is anyone ever going to have the guts to say the word next to SMG's name....Anorexia
 
I wouldn't go so far as to say she is anorexic. From what i have read about SMG's exercise routine etc its seems she really looks after herself. Doesn't smoke, doesn't do drugs and i think i even read somewhere that she hardly drinks.

I think there is a real pressure by Hollywood for actresses to be really skinny. And unfortunately it seems for actresses to get work they have to be slim........its wrong and sad but its true.
 
Is it my imagination or is it not just SMG? I thought Emma Caulfield was much thinner at the end as well...
 
I'll tell you what. Allow me to make the case for why we should consider the possibility SMG has an eating disorder, then you can defeat my arguements and demand an apology.

First of all what Buffster6 says is true:

there is a real pressure by Hollywood for actresses to be really skinny

When this kind of pressure is exerted on a driven, intelligent, individual who demands control over his or her life, and isn't getting it, often what you'll get is an anorexic. This is why anorexia is so common in the arts and entertainment field.

People with eating disorders don't want to be discovered as such. They'll go to great lengths to avoid discovery. Just as with other addictive disorders such as alcholism, they become sneaky. They lie.

Often though, their efforts at obfuscation become in themselves clues.

One thing you'll notice about anorexics is as their disorder worsens their wardrobe will change. They begin to wear longer, baggier clothes designed to hide the now boniness of their frame.

We've seen this happen onscreen to Buffy.

But the wardrobe mistress manages what the star wears, right? SMG has no control over it. Wrong... I saw an interview with SMG recently where she was explaining how she created a character from the outside in, meaning the first thing she examined was what the character looked like, what she wore.

Nevertheless times will occur in a screenplay when the wardrobe is out of the hands of even big stars like SMG.

We saw such an occurence in Get It Done when Buffy had to wear a cocktail dress. View that scene, and look to Buffy's clavicle...Bones.

Another thing to consider in an annorexic's wardrobe is as the condition worsens they begin to get cold, and must wear heavier clothes.

Recently I heard SMG complain about how cold it was in Vancouver when she was filming Scooby Doo Too. I was in Vancouver the same time she was. It wasn't that cold.

Another thing I personally notice about anorexics is a kind of sallowness or sickly look to the skin. This is subjective, so I leave it to you.

The symptoms of anorexia are not all physical. It is a disease that affects the brain, and the way the sufferer interacts in society.

Anorexics avoid the intake of food, but they are obsessed with it. You will often see them arriving at events with gifts of food. It caught my attention when SMG arrived at Angel's opening shoot with a cake. It doesn't prove anything, but it's worth taking note of.

The most obvious psychological clue as to whether or not a person is becoming anorexic is the way they avoid closeness.

Hiding their disorder becomes a priority. If someone gets too close, they might discover the secret. The sufferer of the disorder will go to extremes to push people away, often manipulating events to give them an excuse to do so.

Does everyone remember the rumours of discontent on the Buffy set in the later days. Remember the Alyson Hannigan interview where she let it slip how she was unhappy with SMG for keeping her decision to quit, secret from the cast?

Here's another one. People often get angry at me when I mention it, but it's so obvious it has to be brought out in the open for discussion. SMG has been avoiding the Buffy fans.

Anorexics can have succesful romantic relationships, but if you look into them you will usually notice a great deal of domestic control from the sufferer of the disorder. Anorexia is a disease of control. Again I leave it to you. Is Freddy whipped?

So there you have it, my opening arguements. Go ahead. Rip them apart.
 
While you make excellent points...

I don't wholly agree with you. SMG is like, what? Barely 5 feet tall? Would you expect her to weigh 200 pounds or so? I certainly hope not!

Some people just have that small frame that makes everyone want to puke, but I personally don't go around calling them 'anorexic'. They are just little.

And another point--- It's common for small people to be cold all the time. THey don't have any body fat to insulate the heat. I'm cold sometimes, but I am not anorexic.

I just feel that nobody REALLY knows why she is thin. Maybe in season one she was wearing a wonder-bra or something. And then grew out of that face and because over the years, she has finally ended up with the body she is destined to have... so dont' judge.
 
Alyson Hannigan is naturally thin. Season 7 Alyson is a natural progression from Season 1 Alyson. She has a hot and healthy look about her, thin as she is.

Can you say the same about Sarah. Where did her breasts go? She lost a lot of weight right? I think we're both agreed on that. The question becomes how much is too much? I worry about Sarah. I dream about Alyson.
 
lol nerd4hire i think she is too thin cause i am 14 and she is skinnier than me
 
And I have to add, excercising a lot usually will drop some weight , then adds to your weight by adding muscle. So I would think she would be a little heavier excercising that much.
 
ok SMG lost abit to much weight while she was filming I Know What You Did Last Summer and thats why her breasts got smaller.

SMG is probably at a normal weight, im naturally thin and I only weight around 105-110 sure im 15 but still, someone of SMGs height and she probably has a fast matableism(however you spell it, digests food faster)and is just naturally thin and she probably weighs around 120-140, but we cant really judge her weight since we dont know how much she weighs and also add that she was about 19 when she got the role of Buffy so she still had baby fat to burn.

I probably am skinner then SMG is
 
She lost enough weight in one short stint to go down 2 cup sizes? And she never gained it back Hmmm... That would tell us the weight control is continuing, wouldn't it?

As long as we're guessing weight, I put her around 100. The bulky clothes hide how thin she really is, and the camera puts on 10 pounds.

People generally gain weight after 19, not lose it.

One thing I forgot to point out. Anorexics are often exercise freaks. The fact SMG likes to exercise proves nothing, one way or the other.
 
maybe she is anorexic cause she is skinner than michelle tractenberg!
 
Ok, bulky clothes??? See SMG at award shows I definately would not say she wears bulky clothes.

You do have to remember that SMG is only about 5 foot tall eg. very short!

She was only 19 at the beginning of Season 1 and would still have had puppy fat. We all have noticed that she has lost weight but i still would say she is not anorexic.

SMG would be skinny than MT because SMG is smaller than MT, as pointed out a lot in Buffy episodes.

I was lucky enough to meet Alyson and she is a VERY skinny, i would say she has been thin from the beginning of Buffy but it doesn't mean she doesn't have to work at being that thin. They were all much younger when Buffy started.

And I have to go with Dru Malroy with the Emma Caulfield comment. She is VERY thin. How about when she was dancing in OMWF in that red outfit, i would say she was thinner than SMG.
 
You know, I don't understand it. Someone suggests the possibility SMG may have a physical disorder and people take this approach that's like "Man the castle walls. The barbarian horde approaches. ".

Nobody's saying Sarah is bad or evil or wrong, only that she may be sick. I would think that a true lover of Sarah would want to be aware of such a possibility.

What set me off on my role as messenger of the news, was one of the early posts to this thread where the girl seemed to be wanting to set Sarah up as a role model for weight loss. That's a dangerous policy.

Anorexia is a dangerous, ugly disease, and it's widespread in the entertainment industry. It wouldn't surprise me in the least if Emma Caulfield was also under it's thrall. Were you watching Friends the last 2 Seasons. Jennifer Anniston and Courteney Cox were developing the same undernourished, sickly look apparent in Season 7 Sarah.

Sarah was not wearing baggy clothes when she emceed the award show. Of course not. She would lose Wardrobe control on an award show. If she was attending as a guest she would be stuck in formal wear. Use the opportunity to look at her legs. They're atrophied pins. Anorexia will eat the fat first, then the muscle, then the internal organs.

What's this puppy fat thing you guys are stuck on? Just compare S-1 Sarah to S-7 Sarah. That's not puppy fat she lost.

Sarah is small. So what? Believe it or not, small people get sick too.

Yes Alyson is naturally thin, true, but she looks healthy. Sarah doesn't.
 
i think freddie has something 2 do with her eating habits she lost a lot of weight when they started going out. hmmmmm conspiracy???
 
Back
Top Bottom