lol I think the opposite. I think the first and second season are awesome and then Supernatural kind of falls flat for me and turns well, silly and over-dramatic in the bad sense.
I know what you mean. I was obsessive through seasons 1 and 2, really wasn't fond of the third, and had a hard time following through with 4 and 5. If they just pulled it back a little bit, so it wasn't always, "OMG, DEAN IS SAD. DEAN IS CRYING. OMG SAM IS SAD. SAM IS CRYING. SAM AND DEAN ARE CRYING."
I feel like the later seasons have moments of brilliance though. Castiel is definitely one of them, and I also really like Chuck and his fans. And their spoof episodes are always entertaining.
Taake
couldn't agree more