This or that - episodes

[Puppet]

Phases for being a great Oz piece, having Angelus, and for a much better wolf-suit than that laughable one in B&tB

Hero or You're Welcome?

 

[Mr Trick]

Hero

The Puppet Show or Smile Time?

 

[Ethan Reigns]

The Puppet Show is an actual mystery where you don't know what has to be done whereas Smile Time is just a standard story.

Happy Anniversary or Life Serial (time distortion episodes)?

 

[Mr Trick]

Life Serial easily. Don't rate Happy Anniversary too much.

Family or Fredless?

 

[LilyAnne]

"Family", but "Fredless" is good, too.

"Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered" or "Something Blue"?

 

[Mr Trick]

B,B&B🙂

I Only Have Eyes for You or Are You Now, or Have you Ever Been?

 

[MarieVampSlayer]

I only have eyes for you - I'm a sucker for S2 Bangel!

The Prodigal or Lineage

 

[Puppet]

Lineage - Prodigal is one of my least favorite episodes 🙁

Witch or Nightmares?

 

[MarieVampSlayer]

Humm both are great but I guess Witch because it has some impact in the futur with Amy character!

All the way or Real Me?

 

[Mr Trick]

That's very tough, but actually will go for All the Way😛

I was Made to Love you or Ted?

 

[Willow Tara]

Mr Trick said Family or Fredless?

Oh my god I absolutely love them! For me it would be almost impossible to decide.

"Family", but "Fredless" is good, too.
but I think in the end I'd go with LilyAnne's choice too. But that's really a tough one.

 

[MarieVampSlayer]

Ted - It's not perfect but I just love the serial killer aspect of it!

She or The Cautionary tale or numero cinco ?

 

[Mr Trick]

TCTONC😉 doesn't totally suck wheras She bar two scenes (that dance scene and the coffee bean scene) does!

New Moon Rising or Wild at Heart?

 

[MarieVampSlayer]

New Moon Rising because I was really torned between Tara and Oz and it showed how Amber Benson did a great job with her role as we only knew Tara for a second! Also, no bad actress that plays Veruca!

Bad Girls or Consequences?

 

[LilyAnne]

This is tough. But I guess... "Consequences"

"Buffy vs. Dracula" or "Normal Again"?

 

[MarieVampSlayer]

Normal Again! I love this episode because it screws with my head soooooo much!

Home or Tomorrow?

 

[LilyAnne]

"Home" (Angel's fifth season, like Buffy's, is my favorite, and this is sort of like the first episode of Season 5)

"I Will Remember You" or "You're Welcome"?
(Is this a sacrilege? 😳)

 

[Mr Trick]

You're Welcome simply because I'm not a big Bangel fan. Plus Cordy got the send off she deserved in You're Welcome.

Bad Eggs or The Shroud of Rahmon?

 

[Puppet]

Oh, for some reason I just love The Shroud of Rahmon. All the interactions, the jokes, the twist-ending; it's actually one of the few episodes where I enjoy Kate's presence!

Halloween or Life of the Party?

 

[Skanky Vamp]

Life of the Partay

Harsh Light of Day or In The Dark