I never said that. I only said that Paul can pull of emotional scenes much, much better than David can.
Totally agree. He has the emotional scenes down! The end of episode one didn't break me until I saw Stefan's face. And when he listens outside the door when Elena is trying to comfort Jenna? *sob*
I guess its very hard to judge someone's acting on one scene but I think if you've watched the whole show you can't deny that Paul's acting has massively improved. He's really showing how diverse he can be and I think he'll give Somerhalder a run for his money this season in his "new" role 😉
It's easy to draw comparisons between shows of a similar genre - I see it all the time as a fan of teen dramas but I just like what I like and try and appreciate the ways in which TVD is very different and refreshing and not focus on the way it adheres to conventions.