What makes a witch in the Buffyverse?

Monkey Pants

Bored Now
Joined
Feb 17, 2016
Messages
1,206
Age
35
Black Thorn
This is something that has always confused me. Almost as soon as Willow started doing magic in S2, the Scooby Gang started calling her a witch, even when she couldn't do that much. Sure, she was inherently talented, but she only became super powerful through hard work, practice, and dabbling in some dark magic. It seems to me that she kind of made herself a witch, whereas I assume Tara and Amy were born into it (cus their moms were witches). So then my question is, why does no one in the Scooby Gang consider that other people could be witches too? Anya as a human did a powerful spell to turn Olaf into a troll. I guess she dropped doing spells as a vengeance demon, but when she became human again she still seemed to have a lot of knowledge and talent regarding spells (Dopplegangland), but it's not something she really ever explored again. Dawn was shown being able to do powerful spells (Forever, CWDP), and Buffy did a pretty strong spell on herself in No Place Like Home. And what about Giles and Jonathan? They're definitely warlocks right? So why does no one but Willow try to harness their own magical ability? It seems like most people could become witches if they tried (I mean Tara has been doing it like her whole life and she can't do that much.) My only guess is that they didn't have the hunger to get good at something that Willow did, and figured they could just let her take care of anything magical. But I would think Dawn at least would wanna try instead of just accepting her lowly post as human. Any thoughts?
 
Everyone can. Even Xander could let books burn by speaking Latin in front of it.

It's just that Willow had more talents that allowed her to learn faster and achieve higher levels.
 
Anyone who studies and practices witchcraft can be a witch. Some have more natural talent and power and will be able to reach greater heights or depths. Sorta like musical or athletic ability.
 
Yeah, I just took it that Willow put in the hours of study and practice and so became a powerful witch, whereas others just dabbled.

It's like anyone can kick a ball, but put in the training and you'll become a footballer.
 
Back
Top Bottom