No It's really not and to think otherwise is being a wee bit arrogant imo. Being it is very different to observing it, however sympathetic a person might think they were.
So there we have it, the proclamation that some people will just 'get' aspects of the show better than others simply because of their gender. I wonder what other plot-lines are gender biased in that respect?
Tell me, do you 'get' Buffy as a character more than me simply because you're the same gender and therefore you're inherently more sympathetic to her struggle for womanhood?
🙄
I guess that means that I, as a man, understand any and all male characters (Wesley, Angel, Xander, Spike) better than you ever could because there are just some things a man knows better than a woman...
Seriously, this is where your 'gender politics' argument leads. That way lies madness, not to mention really lazy thinking.
I'll keep my 'arrogant', empathatic tendancies thank you very much. It leads to more reasoned debating.
We don't know that - look at this:
Buffy: Eighteen hundred now, that we've counted. Almost five hundred working with us in ten separate squads.
We know that those slayers don't work with Buffy and that's it.
Exactly. We know that they were found by Buffy and co and yet they don't work for Buffy and co. Logically we can asume that they turned her down because they didn't want to become active slayers, they could choose to have a normal life.
This is what happened to Soledad- she was an illustative tale if you will.
Thing is, Buffy had that choice, since "What's My Line, Part One". Why didn't she quit?
Because Buffy still took orders from the council and was living on the Hellmouth.
Buffy wasn't mature enough to think about going it alone- she was, in some ways, torn between 'normal life' and 'slayer duty'. She complains about being the slayer but when Kendra shows up she feels threatened by the Giles/Kendra closeness.
It's only after 'Helpless' that the scales fall from Buffy's eyes and she really begins to resent how the Council do things, by Graduation Day she's made her choice to go her own way, but by that time she's the only slayer that isn't in a coma.
If Buffy had been really mercenary then she could've murdered Faith in her bed and then fled the Hellmouth I guess, but she's too soft for that.
Why didn't Faith quit in season 8?
Quick answer? Atonement.
On some level Faith feels like she owes it to others to do her duty because of the bad she's done, so she guards the other Hellmouth.
Even then that isn't enough for her not to consider escape, Giles revealed that she's trying to get hold of a fake passport and flee the country. It's only after the mission to assassinate Gigi that Faith regains some focus and purpose.
Why didn't Nikki quit? She had an out, she had a kid.
Well, apparently Nikki tried but she couldn't. Plus she was still 'the one girl in all the world'- not really a lot of options when there are people like Spike out there looking to kill 'the slayer'. She's doomed either way.
I don't think we can just ignore all this and be like oh, slayers can totally ignore their powers, instincts etc when we're shown time and time again that it's not that simple, that they can and probably should for their own sake quit and yet they don't.
But we're not shown that from these new slayers at all. I'm not sure it's even clear that all the new slayers are the same in terms of behaviour compared to Buffy and Faith. Are they all infested with demonic 'vampire killing' essence as well? Or does their power come from the scythe that is linked to, but separate from, the slayer line?
We don't know because we aren't told.
We do see that some slayers simply quit (the ones who Faith trained in London) while others are content to do bodyguarding work for fat stacks of cash. That to me doesn't speak of a restless urge to hunt or kill like Buffy/Faith have exhibited in the past.
All the 'activated slayers' seem to be fairly well-adjusted for the most part:
Dana was crazy/traumatised well before she got her slayer powers.
Gigi was a sociopath manipulated by a murderour warlock.
Simone is violent, gun-happy, power-mad and hates Buffy for what happened in S8.
Their reasons for 'going evil' don't seem linked to the slaying the way Faith's killing of Finch sent her down a dark path- or then again maybe they just weren't as well written.