Croft Storm
God
The general concept of the ending (Buffy can finally let go of her responsibility, Sunnydale destroyed) I though was excellent. Perfect in fact. But the episode itself, didn't like it too much.
Started well with the cool Caleb fight. But last weeks climax, what was that all about?!? The final Buffy cliffhanger seems to suggest that Spike goes evil, but then they just brush it off, pretty disappointing. They should have ended with Caleb rising up again after the first 'kill'.
Then the build up. I'n not complaining about this, it was all good and well, but I thought the Not Fade Away build up had more emotional moments, like Angel with Connor, Spike's poetry, Gunn at the shelter, Wes & illyria etc.
Then the final scene, had it's moments, but mostly I found it underwhelming or lame. Willow goes white- hmm, nice idea I suppose, but kinda silly. There's the inevitable death sequence with Anya, but it wasn't so much a sequence as a quick swipe. We have Spike too, but he comes back in Angel so that's not so special. Then everyone else is just pushed to the background. Final scene with Buffy runing over the buildings, I laughed, which surely isn't the kind of effect the final scene should have. And to finish it off, Dawn gets the last line, which annoyed me a bit.
The thing I really don't like about the finale is how each character didn't really play a part. It was pretty much a case of Spike saves the day, or even the amulet saves the day. This is why i found the gift MUCH better as a series finale, everyone was crucial in their own way (Xander weakens glory with the bulldozer, Anya had the ideas of the Hammer and Orb, Giles finished Ben etc).
So as an episode I'd give Chosen an 9/10. As a season finale I'd give it 8/10. And as a series finale, I'd go for 6/10.
Just for contrast, I'd give the Gift 10,10,10 and Not Fade away a 10,10,9
Started well with the cool Caleb fight. But last weeks climax, what was that all about?!? The final Buffy cliffhanger seems to suggest that Spike goes evil, but then they just brush it off, pretty disappointing. They should have ended with Caleb rising up again after the first 'kill'.
Then the build up. I'n not complaining about this, it was all good and well, but I thought the Not Fade Away build up had more emotional moments, like Angel with Connor, Spike's poetry, Gunn at the shelter, Wes & illyria etc.
Then the final scene, had it's moments, but mostly I found it underwhelming or lame. Willow goes white- hmm, nice idea I suppose, but kinda silly. There's the inevitable death sequence with Anya, but it wasn't so much a sequence as a quick swipe. We have Spike too, but he comes back in Angel so that's not so special. Then everyone else is just pushed to the background. Final scene with Buffy runing over the buildings, I laughed, which surely isn't the kind of effect the final scene should have. And to finish it off, Dawn gets the last line, which annoyed me a bit.
The thing I really don't like about the finale is how each character didn't really play a part. It was pretty much a case of Spike saves the day, or even the amulet saves the day. This is why i found the gift MUCH better as a series finale, everyone was crucial in their own way (Xander weakens glory with the bulldozer, Anya had the ideas of the Hammer and Orb, Giles finished Ben etc).
So as an episode I'd give Chosen an 9/10. As a season finale I'd give it 8/10. And as a series finale, I'd go for 6/10.
Just for contrast, I'd give the Gift 10,10,10 and Not Fade away a 10,10,9
W
Winifred
Agreed...The Gift deserves a rating of 10