Well I am an oddball, and may just throw a wrench in your whole theory.
I'm the older sister of one brother, and I am also 23 (older than your given age range), but I am definitely a Faith fan.
I see faith as misunderstood, neglected, and not bad, but guilty of making bad decisions by default.
I think if buffy hadn't been so self absorbed, that faith's downfall could have been avoided. I always thought that faith was trying to do the best she could, and the betrayal from buffy confused and hurt her. Though I can relate to Buffy, I think she was a bit of a whiner, unlike Faith who embraced her role as a slayer. Truthfully I think Faith would have been an amazing slayer (better than buffy even) if she hadn't been handed the short end of the stick her whole life. And I agree with what someone previously posted, why didn't Joyce or Giles do anything for Faith? I think faith's entire situation was the fault of everyone in the "˜gang' for ignoring her circumstances, and not caring enough about her to give her any guidance.
I think I basically relate to Faith more because of her hard knock life (unlike buffy's rather privileged life), and because she is a bit rough around the edges socially, though she tries her best to do the right thing, she makes mistakes. Plus she's a brunette, lol. Those things are just more real to me than, Buffy's prissy valley-girl mentality.
I'm the older sister of one brother, and I am also 23 (older than your given age range), but I am definitely a Faith fan.
I see faith as misunderstood, neglected, and not bad, but guilty of making bad decisions by default.
I think if buffy hadn't been so self absorbed, that faith's downfall could have been avoided. I always thought that faith was trying to do the best she could, and the betrayal from buffy confused and hurt her. Though I can relate to Buffy, I think she was a bit of a whiner, unlike Faith who embraced her role as a slayer. Truthfully I think Faith would have been an amazing slayer (better than buffy even) if she hadn't been handed the short end of the stick her whole life. And I agree with what someone previously posted, why didn't Joyce or Giles do anything for Faith? I think faith's entire situation was the fault of everyone in the "˜gang' for ignoring her circumstances, and not caring enough about her to give her any guidance.
I think I basically relate to Faith more because of her hard knock life (unlike buffy's rather privileged life), and because she is a bit rough around the edges socially, though she tries her best to do the right thing, she makes mistakes. Plus she's a brunette, lol. Those things are just more real to me than, Buffy's prissy valley-girl mentality.