DeadlyDuo
Scooby
- Joined
- Jul 29, 2016
- Messages
- 9,611
- Age
- 35
I saw your caveat, but by bringing up the race issue you ARE making some sort of equivalency and its a false one. There is no such a thing as vampire prejudice on the show inregards to humans and Spike has not been shown to be 'sensitive' to his vampire nature. He's proud that he's a vampire.
You can be proud of what you are and still encounter insults because of it. "Bat boy" and "Save your lack of breath" are direct jabs about Spike's vampirism. It's possible Faith said those things deliberately in order to redirect Spike's anger towards her thus provoking the physical fight. She can handle him whereas the others would struggle.
Firstly, Faith did actually let Spike speak for a good while and secondly she used multiple phases; 'turn it down a notch' and the like.
You can pick whichever you like to support your POV put she wasn't being bigoted and she wasn't picking a fight, that's the main thing. She was not asking to be hit.
Here's the part of the scene between Spike and Faith:
FAITH
Hey. Why don't you take it down a notch or two? The time for speech-giving is over, bat boy.
SPIKE
(crosses his arms) Oh, is that right?
FAITH
Yeah, that's right. Save your lack of breath.
SPIKE
(shrugs) All right. (punches Faith)
FAITH
You're pretty sweet on her, aren't you? (kicks Spike in the face) I think it's cute. (Spike punches Faith; she punches him back) They way she's got you whipped. (kicks Spike into the other room where he slides over the dining room table and onto the floor)
GILES
Enough!
Faith goes into the dining room after Spike and starts punching him in the face repeatedly. He kicks her off of him and leaps to his feet.
SPIKE
Finally got what you wanted, didn't you? (exchanges punches with Faith) Where is she?
FAITH
I don't know.
Faith tells Spike to "turn it down a notch or two" ONCE before she starts in with the "bat boy" and telling him "the time for speech giving is over". Spike crosses his arms and says " oh, is that right?" He is challenging her and he is displaying very negative body language. Faith then says "Yeah, that's right. Save your lack of breath." She's gone in with the jab about his vampirism again.
It is after that, that Spike punches her. Faith immediately then taunts him about his feelings for Buffy and hits him a lot more than he hits her. She wasn't just reacting to a situation, she was feeding it. She's not an idiot, she knew what she was doing.
Faith was the one who actually tried to deescalate that particular confrontation- nobody else did- and also went out after Buffy. That's a lot given that she is an outside in this instance.
Not really. She just didn't want the responsibility of leader. Faith wasn't exactly defending Buffy or trying to mediate between Buffy and everyone else, she said her piece against Buffy just like everyone else did.
Buffy left, of her own choice, because the choices she made and has been making.
Again, not really. She said that she couldn't stay and watch Faith lead them all into disaster (which she was right about) and Dawn told her "Then you can't stay here. Buffy, I love you, but you were right. We have to be together on this. You can't be a part of it. So I need you to leave. I'm sorry, but this is my house, too."
That's not really giving Buffy a choice.
Spike's 'deductions' are ill-informed and wrong on almost every level, as has previously been stated. It might not be rocket science but its clearly beyond his ability to comprehend.
SPIKE
So, uh, Buffy took some time off right in the middle of the apocalypse, and it was her decision?
XANDER
Well, we all decided.
SPIKE
Oh, yeah. You all decided. You sad, sad, ungrateful traitors. Who do you think you are?
WILLOW
We're her friends. We just want—
SPIKE
Oh, that's ballsy of you. You're her friends, and you betray her like this?
I'd say Spike is pretty spot on with his "deductions".
Or, to use less emotive language, the decided not to follow her on yet another suicide mission against an unbeatable foe they still knew nothing about. Hardly backstabbing since everything was out in the open. Buffy called the meeting, got defensive when people refused to 'fall into line', and then left because her pride wouldn't let her work with others.
Buffy was right though. Perhaps it's a failure in the writing where the audience is meant to see both points of view, but at the end of the day, Buffy was correct whilst the others were wrong.
Not really, Spike was getting himself more and more worked up as the scene goes along.
Which is why it's likely Faith deliberately said what she did in order to redirect his anger towards her.
Actually Faith did stand up for Buffy- she told the Potentials that Buffy was the one they wanted, their leader, that she was not.
She simply said that Buffy needed a break (true) but then Buffy started in on Faith and so it didn't last.
Go watch the scene again, Faith standing up for Buffy is there, but she wasn't going to get between Buffy and her friends/family, perhaps she thinks that she hadn't got the right given all that history.
Faith just didn't want the responsibility of leadership. She'd rather Buffy have that role and have to make the hard decisions.
Your characterization of both Faith (and even Kennedy) in those instances is deeply unfair.
No, my characterisation of Kennedy is quite accurate. Kennedy openly admits that she thought she'd get a bigger say with Faith in charge. In the scene directly after Buffy leaves and everybody is trying to talk at once, Xander says "You know, I'm thinking that everyone here shouldn't have a say" and Kennedy's response is "I just wonder if those of us who have been here longer should have more of a say."
Since Kennedy is the only one of the original potentials left, she clearly means herself. Given that Kennedy suggests that and then later openly admits that she thought she'd get a bigger say with Faith in charge, it very strongly points to Kennedy initiating the mutiny to serve her self-interest rather than the good of the team.
Everyone being reluctant to return to the vineyard is understandable (and it was bad timing on Buffy's part), but it is Kennedy who throws in the "Let's vote to have Faith in charge". The evidence just mounts up that Kennedy is a very horrible person who only cares about her self-interest.
To the Potentials, not to Giles and the others. In that scene in the kitchen everyone is pretty equal. Dawn, Willow and Giles are busily discussing the Bringer and what to do to get info. Then Faith lets Willow try and explain to Spike what happened, etc.
The scoobies have known Spike the longest, hence why the "bad news" would be better coming from one of them. Given that Giles was recently part of a plot to kill Spike, he was kind of out of the running so it was left to either Willow or Xander. Given that Xander and Spike didn't always see eye to eye, that kind of left Willow as the bearer of bad news.
I gotta say, for somebody who calls Riley abusive and counts the number of times he grabs Buffy, you seem pretty okay with Spike lashing out whenever he feels like it.
I call Riley controlling, he never quite crosses the threshold into abusive. Also the writers don't try to paint Spike as this wholesome guy Buffy should want to be with, unlike what they did with Riley.
Chill out.
You began the sarcasm, I was just matching you.