What will the word of mouth be like.
The Critics don't matter. Ebert, for instance, has panned almost every popular Genre movie that's come along including the first 2 entries in the Lord of the Rings trilogy. Didn't hurt them.
I'm trying to get a handle on past sleeper movie cult phenomena. The new generation of (US) PG-13 horror flicks have done really well. From what I've read, it's primarily driven by teens, teen girls especially. The Ring movies, Grudge, this new Exorcism of Emily Rose"”all sort of surprising the industry and media pundits at how relatively huge they turn out to be.
I suspect that reviews matter most for the arthouse flicks and the potential Oscar contenders. The folks who read the alternative weeklys and Entertainment Weekly, Variety, etc. pay attention to the critical buzz much more than your average grade schooler, high schooler...
The Others, The Sixth Sense were twisty, surprising stories that pulled the rug on folks, led to slow-building word-of-mouth...
Serenity is a different animal altogether I think. I don't see its promotion appealing to teen girls all that much like a PG-13 horror flick. Teen boys, maybe"”with all the action in the TV spot(s). It seems like a hard sell. It'll be smart and odd enough to be something the arthouse crowd could seemingly get into, yet so many would be repelled by the genre right off the bat.
It's weird, it's got a built-in little Star Wars cult before anything even hits the big screen. Sort of like a potential mainstream nerd-backlash factor...
And the most influential US critic, Ebert, is an odd duck. He didn't like the first two LOTR movies cause he felt Jackson changed the tone, original Hobbit emphasis of the books too much.
Ebert, I think, likes most 007 films, liked virtually all the Marvel movies (excepting Spidey 1), loved Sky Captain...even the mindless Tomb Raider flicks! But, he needs something to glom onto, like a retro-nostalgia, comic book adventure factor...or Angelina Jolie, heh.
What's gonna happen with Serenity!?!