Spike or Angel?

You need to decide for yourselves weather it's worth dying for
A choice.
Angel never started the Appocolypse, The mere fact that the Demons were Gunning just for Angel and his crew, says it all.He put a spoke in the works said so himself in not fade away, if anyone started the Appocolyps it was the senior partners.

Why are people saying that Angel was in love with Darla? He wasn't ,he was seeing his redemption in helping her see hers and when W&H put a spanner in the works Angel took steps to rid himself of feeling by having sex with Darla he was hoping to rid himself of ALL feelings.
And how is that relevent to wether you prefer Angel or Spike?
*Walks* away shakes head.....
 
Still has no relevance to our discussion. I agree, she was a stronger vampire, Spike is a stronger human.
Spike's not human, and when he was he was a snivelling weak human!

I never said he did it for the greater good. The fact of the matter is, it doesn't actually matter why Spike got his soul. What matters is, when he got it he used it for the greater good. Angel spent 100 years before using his.

But Spike merely showed a few months of remorse when he got his soul, Angel manages to show constant remorse, but still do good. Spike has showed that he really doesn't care about the people he has killed up until Damage:

SPIKE
Come to tap-dance on the patient, have we, doc? I'd give you the finger, but apparently I won't have the motor skills till the drugs wear off.

ANGEL
(walks in)
A lot of pain?

SPIKE
More than I'd like. But not as much as you would. Just what I deserve.

ANGEL
(sighs)
I didn't say that.

SPIKE
No. I did. The lass thought I killed her family. And I'm supposed to what, complain 'cause hers wasn't one of the hundreds of families I did kill? I'm not saying' you're right... 'cause, uh... I'm physically incapable of saying that. But, uh... for a demon... I never did think that much about the nature of evil. No. Just threw myself in. Thought it was a party. I liked the rush. I liked the crunch. Never did look back at the victims.
Spike as realised that the way he has been dealing with the people he murdered was wrong, he should not have been ignoring them.
The first part I highlighted shows that Spike can't deal with this pain, he is too weak to control it. Angel on the other hand can control it, and do good at the same time.
The second part shows that he does agree that Angel's moping is right, he only doesn't say it cuz he won't admit to being wrong(Arrogance)

Angel had sex with Darla, which is much worse than Spike and Harmony.
Ha, yeah right, how so?
Angel also didn't have sex with Darla until episode 15 of season 2, that's almost 2 years after graduation day, and a year after he had last seen Buffy.
Spike had last seen Buffy about 5 months before he had sex with Harmony.

Wanting to be loved does not make you a bad man. It just makes you a man.
This is often a thing associated with rape, to make the victim feel 'love'. So yes it can make you a bad man!

Yes, and he went to Italy just to help her there as well. Have you watched Chosen, the majority of their conversation is about them being with each other.
He did actually go to Buffy to help her, he thought she was in danger with The Immortal, His petty rampage began after he found out she wasn't in danger but dating him!
And yes the majority of the conversation about them being together, but in a couple of years, not at that moment in time!

So it's ok for Angel to have selfish reasons for fighting evil, but not Spike. You are using two different sticks to measure both vampires.
No I'm not; I am using the same stick.
Spike got the soul for a selfish reason.
Angel only found out about that he could be made human a year after he left Buffy!

that was David Fury. About five minutes after he said that, he also said Spike was a better man than Angel. But I guess now that I'm using your argument against you, its now not important?
Sorry yes you are correct it was DF, and he said that in his own opinion Spike was that better man and that he thought Spike should be the one to become human. (Thank god DF is not was not as in control as Joss!)

And? Spike had a soul how long? two years. Angel had his fifty-plus times that.
Yes he did, so the same argument could be applied to you saying Spike never did anything as bad as Angel, by leaving the lawyers to die.


Do you think Angel is arrogant?
No,


And then on the rest:
There was no love between Darla and Angel!!
 
Spike's not human, and when he was he was a snivelling weak human!

William was not a weak man. Where you getting this? You're judging him by his lack of cool as a human.

Liam was a drunkard, a womaniser. He had not the courage to be his own person, to become a man, always in the shadow of his father. Harmony as Cordelia so aptly put it, was a sheep, never daring to be different, not having the courage. William dared to be different. See the scene he asked Cecily out?? He knew she'd more than likely reject him, but he dared anyway. He had the strength(not much, but certainly more than Liam and Harm) to ask, Liam and Harmony were both much weaker than Liam. Do not judge mental strength on coolness.


But Spike merely showed a few months of remorse when he got his soul, Angel manages to show constant remorse, but still do good. Spike has showed that he really doesn't care about the people he has killed up until Damage:

Stop talking out your ass, wee man. Spike asked Buffy to kill him, because the remorse he felt when he killed those people in sunnydale and buried them in the cellar. That was people he killed, WHEN HE WAS NOT IN CONTROL. How do you think he feels about people he killed when he was in full control. You're desperatley trying to argue the same points over and over, but you gain absolutely no ground. Explain to me what Spike can do for the people he killed around the year 1900, or 1901, or 1902. Nothing. He can do nothing for them. All he can do is help those that need him, and thats what he does. Angel spent 100 years being too weak, too afraid to actually do anything. He was filled with self loathing, if you want to argue thats a good thing, well good luck with that. YOU WILL GET NO LEE-WAY from this end. Angel was a self loathing useless loser for 100 years. Spike was for what, 2 months?

Spike as realised that the way he has been dealing with the people he murdered was wrong, he should not have been ignoring them.
You're right! He should not be ignoring the people he killed! He should ask them round for tea! Maybe He should have asked Buffy to help dig them up!

The first part I highlighted shows that Spike can't deal with this pain, he is too weak to control it. Angel on the other hand can control it, and do good at the same time.

100 years vs couple of months. Figure it out.

The second part shows that he does agree that Angel's moping is right, he only doesn't say it cuz he won't admit to being wrong(Arrogance)

Are you retarded? Seriously, do you have some sort of learning difficulty?

Ha, yeah right, how so?
Angel also didn't have sex with Darla until episode 15 of season 2, that's almost 2 years after graduation day, and a year after he had last seen Buffy.
Spike had last seen Buffy about 5 months before he had sex with Harmony.

That has nothing to do with Buffy. Darla is a mass murdering serial killer. Harmony's just useless(and also not killing when Spike porks her), there is a big difference between the two. Your own argument regarding Harmony lends to this.

This is often a thing associated with rape, to make the victim feel 'love'. So yes it can make you a bad man!

Huh? WHat does "it can" have to do with anything. Spike's wanting to be loved made him a better man. Can happen has nothing to do with it, because it didn't.

He did actually go to Buffy to help her, he thought she was in danger with The Immortal, His petty rampage began after he found out she wasn't in danger but dating him!

Ye...good luck with that.
And yes the majority of the conversation about them being together, but in a couple of years, not at that moment in time!

She gave him the brush off for captain peroxide. Thats why their conversation became about the future, and not that moment in time.

No I'm not; I am using the same stick.
Spike got the soul for a selfish reason.
Angel only found out about that he could be made human a year after he left Buffy!

You mean you're using the same old shtick. I thought so, damnit!
Sorry yes you are correct it was DF, and he said that in his own opinion Spike was that better man and that he thought Spike should be the one to become human. (Thank god DF is not was not as in control as Joss!)

I don't recall him saying Spike should be the one to become human, but his opinion(Him being a writer on the show) was that Spike was a better man. Heck, he was writing for the characters, he must have a better eye for the situation.
Yes he did, so the same argument could be applied to you saying Spike never did anything as bad as Angel, by leaving the lawyers to die.

No it can't. That sort of lack-brained thinking is typical of your argument. By your reasoning I could say, its possible Angel could go nuts and kill 1000 people, so Spikes a better man, because he won't. Because what might happen is irrelevant. I'm not judging Spike and Angel 10 years from now, 20, whatever. Alley, last known location, Spike is a better man.
 
PJ, Spike shoud not of ignored the victims, he killed, basically what Black eyed guy is trying to say is Spike should of shown a bit more remorse rather that get all blase about it.
Angel as Angelus did more wicked things than Spike, that is why he has a bigger bout of guilt then Spike, But on the subject of them going to Italy, they both went to win over buffy, they did not want to go before until they heard about the immortal, then the bikkering began.
I suppose Spike would of handled being screwed over by w&h over Darla, which resulted in shutting the lawyers inside wine celler alot better hey?

One other thing don't be so rude in your post over your objection with Black Eyed guy it is not very mature you can do better than that surely?
 
K
Kimm
I agree....there really is no reason for name calling....
i do like both angel and spike. It's way to hard to choose since both characters are very easy to fall in love with. Spike is a very intresting vamp since he was still sweet even without a soul he still could have human compasion ( even tho chip was there) But angel is just so nice and his puppy eyes are so cute.. i just don't get how a man that hot can be possibly..🙂 Angel really cares about the world, spike did save the world and he was a very good man/vamp but also angel saved ppl alot. so liek i said i can't choose.

ps. spike is funnier tho 🙂
 
PJ, Spike shoud not of ignored the victims, he killed, basically what Black eyed guy is trying to say is Spike should of shown a bit more remorse rather that get all blase about it.
Angel as Angelus did more wicked things than Spike, that is why he has a bigger bout of guilt then Spike, But on the subject of them going to Italy, they both went to win over buffy, they did not want to go before until they heard about the immortal, then the bikkering began.
I suppose Spike would of handled being screwed over by w&h over Darla, which resulted in shutting the lawyers inside wine celler alot better hey?
:violin:
One other thing don't be so rude in your post over your objection with Black Eyed guy it is not very mature you can do better than that surely?


No.


Spike, because he has a personality.

Quoted for truth, justice and soccer moms.
 
Ok Well I'm not going to quote your last reply and then argue each of your points, like we have been doing for a while now, just because there is no point cuz you will just do the same back and we will never stop until we get told to shut up. And the thread will probably be closed soon as it has gone over it's 100 post's limit.

So just to sum up the argument: PJ you are wrong, thanks it's been fun!
 
Your not the winner if nobody will bother to respond to you, and since you are going to point out everyone spelling mistakes:

You're desperatley trying to argue the same points over and over, but you gain absolutely no ground
desperately

I don't read comics, so I have no idea about Fray. How anyone can say an apocolypse turning out in the favour of good, is beyond
Apocalypse(And that one was a constant mistake through out the thread!)

Now I know I can't spell, that's why I don't go about pointing out others mistakes. Maybe PJ you should concentrate on your own spelling instead of correcting others!

So with no one caring about what PJ has to say, I think we can close the thread!
 
Your not the winner if nobody will bother to respond to you, and since you are going to point out everyone spelling mistakes:


desperately


Apocalypse(And that one was a constant mistake through out the thread!)

Now I know I can't spell, that's why I don't go about pointing out others mistakes. Maybe PJ you should concentrate on your own spelling instead of correcting others!

So with no one caring about what PJ has to say, I think we can close the thread!


Wow, two spelling mistakes(in ten zillion words), accidently mispelled, not intentionally spelled that way because I didn't know how to spell those two words.
Did you look through all my posts in this thead? That is really pathetic.

"Apocalypse(And that one was a constant mistake through out the thread!)"

Bullshit. If I have mispelled it more than twice I will be shocked.

Keep sucking, you're good at it.
 
No I noticed them when you posted and I was only bothered to look over the last 3 pages cuz I knew were they were.

And That apocalypse one is true have a look!
 
Back
Top Bottom