Who deserves Hell more? Faith, Spike, or Warren

J

Joshua

Huge Spuffy Fan!
Joined
Nov 23, 2011
Messages
1,392
Age
34
Location
Sunnydale
Which big bad do you think deserved Hell the most? Faith Lehane, William the Bloody or Warren?
 
Warren hands down. He is human, souled, has no excuse and does never show remorse. Faith is second, she is human, souled but has 'some' excuse and shows remorse. William the Bloody would need a soul to go to Hell but his soul doesn't deserve Hell because it's not responsible for the demon's evil deeds
 
Depends on how much William's poems suck. If his poems caused lots of reader deaths (like how "A Hitchhiker's Guide to Galaxy" describes), I think it's him.
 
Anya - yes, I know she's on the list but her body count was astronomical - many times that of the entire FF combined. She didn't chose to stop being a vengeance demon - her power source was destroyed. She didn't regret what she had done - in fact she enjoyed remembering and talking about her most creative tortures.

And she did all of this with a soul.
 
Warren, people like him deserve to go to the "special" hell (Firefly reference).

With Faith, becoming evil was the result of everyone being against her (from her POV).

When Spike did all of those 'bad' things, he didn't have a soul (not that the soul changed much...).
 
They all committed terrible crimes (Anya too) so I think the choice has to be based on level of guilt or regret, so it has to be Warren, who felt on guilt for his actions and instead blamed his victims
 
Certainly not Glory! She would have made that place her party zone! 😛


bespangeled said:
Anya - yes, I know she's on the list but her body count was astronomical - many times that of the entire FF combined. She didn't chose to stop being a vengeance demon - her power source was destroyed. She didn't regret what she had done - in fact she enjoyed remembering and talking about her most creative tortures.

And she did all of this with a soul.
Click to expand...

Agreed.

Otherwise Warren for reasons already stated, namely lack of remorse.

Faith faced up to her crimes and attempts to atone them which is something.

William the Bloody, well... as a demon, unless he Shansu's, it seems likely that he would go to hell just because. I doubt the pearly gates are open to bloodsucking fiends. Now that he has a soul... I'm not sure. Does having a soul, for either him or Angel, make up for all the lives they took when soulless? Is that something you ever could atone for? Does remorse make up for centuries of death? They are still demons after all, demons with souls, but demons nonetheless. I'm not sure. Best they better stay alive.
 
Snyder
Snyder
I love your banner :D
But did Anya have her soul when she was a vengeance demon? I thought all demons were unsouled!
 
Taake said:
Does having a soul, for either him or Angel, make up for all the lives they took when soulless? Is that something you ever could atone for? Does remorse make up for centuries of death? They are still demons after all, demons with souls, but demons nonetheless. I'm not sure. Best they better stay alive.
Click to expand...

you think the human's soul pays for the sins of the demon that kills them? but that would be unfair 🙁
 
Snyder said:
you think the human's soul pays for the sins of the demon that kills them? but that would be unfair 🙁
Click to expand...

Yeah, I'm kind of not sure, haha. I was thinking of when Buffy killed Angel and he got sucked into Acathla... maybe the hell dimension he was in was due to Acathala and not Angel's own deeds... but technically he died and went to hell, soul and all.
 
Taake said:
Yeah, I'm kind of not sure, haha. I was thinking of when Buffy killed Angel and he got sucked into Acathla... maybe the hell dimension he was in was due to Acathala and not Angel's own deeds... but technically he died and went to hell, soul and all.
Click to expand...

yeah there are few things we can be really sure of 😀
Acathla, I remember but I never thought that Angel really died because Buffy put a sword in him not a stake in his heart so how could he die? and I thought it was a hell dimension, like the one Connor went to
 
Taake
Taake
ah, yeah, that makes sense now that you mention it. Fair point!
Warren without a doubt. He showed absolutely no remorse in the tv show or comics.
 
Snyder said:
But did Anya have her soul when she was a vengeance demon? I thought all demons were unsouled!
Click to expand...
I refuse to believe that Clem and Merl are unsouled.

Lorne, on the other hand, might actually be unsouled, according to his haters.
 
I'll go with Warren. I'm a bit bias cause I love Faith. But I don't know if Warren could or would ever want to seek redemption. Spike was a demon without a soul, so it's in his nature to do evil things.
 
vellavu said:
I refuse to believe that Clem and Merl are unsouled.
Click to expand...

I understand you but on the other hand it would make no sense that some demons are souled and some are not. I think only humans have souls because in a way that's what a soul is, humanity, isn't it?

vellavu said:
Lorne, on the other hand, might actually be unsouled, according to his haters.
Click to expand...

Lorne has haters? color me shocked!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom