- Jul 29, 2016
I dislike the fact that they brought people who either should have stayed dead or people who like Fred soul was destroyed .Illyria pretended to be Fred & The First took the appearance of Warren because he died from Willow's dark magic. Both were dead, it's not the same. Illyria & The First just took their appearances , that's all.
Both were meant to stay dead before Whedon change the story & lie about it. Fred's soul was destroyed in ATS S5. It was tragic, moving & great as a story. And it was good like that. I don't like when characters get brought back to life after that it was clear that they won't come back.
I also LOVED that Willow flayed Warren in S6.
Tbh that was a problem on the show too not just the comics.I loved the comics, but I agree bringing back people from the dead meant there was absolutely no jeopardy at all which removed much of the excitement of the comics as no one was at any real risk. They did leave Cordy, Tara and Wesley for dead, but I wish they'd also left Giles and didn't bring him back.
I don't think it was the same. I was happy to see Buffy come back from the dead. I didn't want the show to end with just another dead slayer, that to me would have been a waste of five seasons (plus season 6 & 7 are my favourites). I'm glad Joyce and Tara were left in peace. I didn't care about Jesse, so he was no loss to me. I was glad Angel returned so we could see him on his own show, and of course I was happy to see Spike again. None of those returns felt unearned to me, and they all added so much to the verse I'm glad they happened.Tbh that was a problem on the show too not just the comics.
Joss was involved in S8 and S9 including the Space sex and TGIQ recon and the abortion storyline and how it ended. Both he and the other Comic writers/producers confirmed that was all Joss.I think of the comics as being soft canon to the shows' hard canon. A bit like Pottermore - yeah, sure JKR is inventing that stuff and says it's real but ... it's not in the books so it doesn't really count. And if she decided to write another Harry book or a marauder era book, or even a founders book - she isn't going to cross reference every inane titbit she posted onto Pottermore to make sure nothing in the new hard canon contradicts the old soft canon and that would be no big deal. Tey'd just quietly change the soft canon. But if something she wrote in her new hard canon book contradicted something from the original series ... I mean my head might explode, or I'd have to find a way to headcanon it and make it fit. The films aren't actually canon because they're only 'based' on the book and 'cursed child ' ... well, the less said the better but the fact that it wasn't written by the actual creator and is written for another medium is enough for me to disregard completely.
I feel the same way about the comics - I know Joss wrote some of them, but certainly not all of them and wasn't even involved in plenty of them. They're a completely different medium, they would be disregarded in a moment if it became convenient to do so and they apparently already directly contradict hard canon (how can somebody forget Warren is dead?) so that much cannot be canon of any variety. The only reason I consider them soft canon and not out and out published fan fiction (like those Buffy books that were written back at the time - I read one called Monster Island about Doyle's dad being a member of The Scourge. It's a properly published book but CLEARLY not canon) is because Joss has said they're canon but ... Joss forgot Warren was dead. I'm not accepting his word as a literal truth, if his grasp on the show is getting that shaky - but I'll accept it as a half baked one.
I don't read the comics, though - I'm not a comic book fan in general so the change of medium was deeply unappealing to me, and then absolutely nothing I've ever heard of them makes me want to find out more. I'm not sure I've ever heard of a Buffyverse comic book story line where my immediate reaction wasn't 'well that sounds stupid.' Had the contents of the comics been the show - I wouldn't be posting on these boards 20 years later.