AnthonyCordova
By suffering, learning
Interstellar: 6/10
Tries too hard to be something it is not (profound). It feels like the product of people who are really enthusiastic about making something profound but don't have any real experiences of their own with that. The last 30 minutes really bothered me too. Do we really need every last detail explained and spelled out for us (McConoghey monologues)? They assume the audience to be that stupid. The magic of the movie gets fatally compromised in the process. It's like performing an impressive magic trick but then going on to explain for 30 minutes in pedantic detail every last aspect of the trick. And also, that kind of detailed explanation deprives the audience of the subjective experience of giving the movie meaning for themselves. Look at 2001: Space Odyssey. They resolved in 3 minutes of a quick succession of sequences what took Interstellar 30 anti-climactic minutes. It is okay to allow the audience space to fill in the gaps. That's what keeps people talking about 2001 Space Odyssey 30 years or more later. And sometimes what you DON'T say is as important and meaningful as what you do say. Interstellar is visually impressive but rather pedantic in terms of content and development.
Tries too hard to be something it is not (profound). It feels like the product of people who are really enthusiastic about making something profound but don't have any real experiences of their own with that. The last 30 minutes really bothered me too. Do we really need every last detail explained and spelled out for us (McConoghey monologues)? They assume the audience to be that stupid. The magic of the movie gets fatally compromised in the process. It's like performing an impressive magic trick but then going on to explain for 30 minutes in pedantic detail every last aspect of the trick. And also, that kind of detailed explanation deprives the audience of the subjective experience of giving the movie meaning for themselves. Look at 2001: Space Odyssey. They resolved in 3 minutes of a quick succession of sequences what took Interstellar 30 anti-climactic minutes. It is okay to allow the audience space to fill in the gaps. That's what keeps people talking about 2001 Space Odyssey 30 years or more later. And sometimes what you DON'T say is as important and meaningful as what you do say. Interstellar is visually impressive but rather pedantic in terms of content and development.